A Wholesome Two-Layer Dog Cake for a Special Birthday
Fresh shredded carrots hold onto moisture during baking so the sponge layers stay soft inside this homemade carrot dog cake.
Shredded carrots add moisture to the interior of A Layered Carrot Dog Cake With Fluffy Potato Frosting as it bakes for 25 minutes. The batter incorporates whole wheat flour. Whipping cooked potatoes produces a realistic coating that resembles ordinary buttercream while providing a lower-fat alternative to heavy dairy or nut butters.
Carrot Cake
The base layers start with a simple wet mix. You whisk eggs, peanut butter, oil, honey, and milk together in a bowl. The eggs provide protein. The peanut butter brings a strong scent that dogs notice immediately. You do not need a smooth liquid here. Small specks of unmixed peanut butter will melt into the batter later.
Stir the shredded carrots directly into the liquid mixture. The carrots supply moisture to the baked sponge. You can substitute sweet potato, or use zucchini instead. If dairy is a concern, water easily replaces the milk. The honey can also be completely omitted if you do not want any sweetness in the batter.
Add the whole wheat flour and baking soda to the bowl. The flour supplies carbohydrates and the baking soda acts as a leavening agent. Gently stir the dry items into the wet mixture. Stop stirring the moment the dry patches disappear. Too much stirring creates a hard sponge.
Divide the finished batter between two 8-inch (20 cm) pans. Push the batter to the edges and flatten the tops. The recipe uses a very small amount of oil. This equates to about half a teaspoon per slice.
Bake the pans at 350°F (180°C) for 25 minutes. Pull them from the oven when a skewer inserted into the center pulls out clean. Let the layers sit on a wire rack until they cool down to room temperature.
Fluffy Potato Frosting
Traditional frosting relies on high amounts of fat. This cooked potato base offers a lower-fat alternative to heavy dairy or nut butters.
Boil or steam the potato chunks until they are extremely soft and easily pierced. Put the hot potatoes in a bowl with plain unsweetened yogurt. The yogurt adds probiotics to support digestion. Extra yogurt or peanut butter makes the frosting too high in fat. You can substitute water for the yogurt if you need a dairy-free option.
Whip the hot potatoes and yogurt with an electric beater on medium speed for about 1 1/2 minutes.
Splash in a little water to thin out the mixture. You want to reach a consistency that spreads easily.
Assembly
The frosting requires warm application. It firms up as it cools down. A cold potato frosting becomes too stiff to spread.
Place one cooled cake layer on a serving plate. Scoop a quarter of the warm potato mixture onto it and push it out to the edges.
Set the second cake layer directly on top. Set aside three-quarters of a cup of the frosting for piping. Use the rest of the warm mixture to coat the top and sides of the stacked cakes.
Fill a piping bag with your saved frosting and pipe a border around the top edge.
This finished two-layer cake is large. You should cut it into slices and share it among multiple dogs.
A Wholesome Two-Layer Dog Cake for a Special Birthday
Carrot Cake
- 2 eggs
- 2.5 cup shredded carrots, from about 2 large
- 2 cup whole wheat flour, or wholemeal or white flour
- 2.5 tsp baking soda
- 0.5 cup peanut butter, spread or pure
- 0.25 cup canola or vegetable oil
- 0.67 cup milk, or water
- 0.33 cup honey, or maple syrup, applesauce, or omit entirely
Fluffy Potato Frosting
- 1.2 lb potatoes, peeled and cut into chunks
- 0.75 cup plain unsweetened yogurt, or water
Ingredients
- 2.5 cup shredded carrot, 2 large
We may earn a small commission from grocery & equipment links, at no cost to you. Disclosure.
Method
Carrot Cake
Fluffy Potato Frosting
Assembly
Substitutions
If dairy is a concern, replace the milk in the Carrot Cake and the yogurt in the Fluffy Potato Frosting with water.
You can use grated sweet potato or zucchini instead of carrots for the cake layers.
Serving
A Layered Carrot Dog Cake With Fluffy Potato Frosting is quite large and is intended to be shared among multiple dogs.
Common mistakes
Do not overmix the Carrot Cake batter once you add the dry ingredients, or you will end up with a hard sponge.
Do not let the Fluffy Potato Frosting cool down before the Assembly stage, as it sets and becomes too stiff to spread.
Avoid using excessive amounts of yogurt or peanut butter to prevent the treat from becoming too high in fat.
Techniques
It is perfectly fine if whisking the wet ingredients leaves small specks of unmixed peanut butter in the bowl.
Always let baked cake layers cool completely on a wire rack before decorating them so the layers do not crumble or slide.
Test the center of your bakes with a wooden skewer to ensure they are fully cooked before pulling them from the oven.
Can I use a different vegetable instead of carrots?
Yes, replacing the shredded carrots with grated sweet potato or zucchini works perfectly. Both of these vegetables provide the moisture needed to keep the baked sponge soft inside.
Is there a way to make this completely dairy-free?
Yes, you can easily make this dairy-free. Simply replace the milk in the Carrot Cake and the yogurt in the Fluffy Potato Frosting with equal amounts of water.
How much of this cake should I feed my dog at once?
A Layered Carrot Dog Cake With Fluffy Potato Frosting is quite large and contains ingredients meant for sharing. You should cut it into slices and share it among multiple dogs rather than serving it as a single portion.
Why did my sponge turn out dense and hard?
You likely overmixed the Carrot Cake batter after adding the whole wheat flour and baking soda. You must gently stir the dry ingredients in and stop the exact moment the dry patches disappear to avoid a tough bake.
Why is my potato frosting impossible to spread?
You probably let it cool down before the Assembly stage. The Fluffy Potato Frosting must be applied while it is still warm, because it sets and becomes too stiff to spread once it reaches room temperature.
Can I add extra peanut butter to give it more flavor?
Avoid using excessive amounts of peanut butter in the cake batter or adding extra yogurt to the frosting. Doing so will make the treat too high in fat for your dog to digest comfortably.
Should I be worried about small lumps of peanut butter in the wet mix?
No, it is perfectly fine if whisking the wet ingredients leaves small specks of unmixed peanut butter in the bowl. These little pieces will simply melt into the batter as the cake bakes.
How can I tell when a sponge cake is fully baked?
Test the center of your bakes by sliding a wooden skewer into the middle. If it pulls out clean without any wet batter clinging to it, the cake is fully cooked and ready to be removed from the oven.
Why do I need to let the cake layers cool before decorating?
Always let baked cake layers cool completely on a wire rack before applying any toppings. Frosting a warm cake can cause the layers to crumble or make the decoration melt and slide right off the sides.
Add a private note
Private to this device - jot your tweaks, swaps and timings. (Syncs to your account later.)
What to serve with it
See all →
You might also like
See all →
The Friday 3-recipe dinner plan 🧡
Every Friday: three tested weeknight dinners + one shopping list, ready to go. No spam, ever - unsubscribe anytime.